One Dollar's Path Through the Vehicle
An SPV investor owns part of a vehicle that holds company shares or a note. Its cash passes through that vehicle on the way in and out. Fees and carry reduce what returns, while the manager's decision rights and payout rules affect when it arrives.
ILPA's guidance calls for clear fund economics and expense allocation. In an SPV, the investor's cash pays for shares and costs, while sale proceeds may pass through further charges on the way back. That full path determines the return the investor keeps.
A 2% management fee and 20% carry are familiar headline terms. To work out their cost, the LP also needs to know when each charge applies and what amount it is based on.
A $10 million cheque may buy less than $10 million of shares if costs come out before closing. Carry can then reduce the sale proceeds before the LP gets paid. The company may do as well as planned while the LP's net multiple falls short.
The SPV is part of the investment
The SPV remains part of the investment after closing. Its manager may control later cheques, company reports and payouts of cash or shares. Those choices can change both the amount the LP receives and how long it waits.
Carta studied 442 US SPVs with more than $10 million of assets formed from 2016 to 2023. Just over half held between $10 million and $20 million. The size of these vehicles gives context, but their fee terms determine how much of each cheque buys shares.
The Rate, Fee Base and Timing Work Together
Carta found that 44% of SPVs charged management fees. Among the vehicles that did charge one, the 2023 median was 1.9%. That statistic tells an investor how common a fee is, but not how expensive a particular vehicle will be.
| Cost | Why It Matters |
|---|---|
| Management fee | Reduces capital available for the investment or distributions. |
| Carry | Shares upside with the sponsor after defined thresholds or return of capital. |
| Setup costs | Legal, formation, and closing expenses can be material in smaller vehicles. |
| Administration | Ongoing reporting, tax, and audit work may be passed through. |
A 2% fee charged once costs less than the same fee charged each year on the same base. That base also matters: committed and invested capital may differ. Setup and admin costs can then reduce the cheque further or require extra cash.
The rate, its base and its duration together explain the fee. ILPA Principles 3.0 applies this logic to fees and expenses and also addresses carry, co-investments and conflicts. These details explain the gap between the subscription and the shares purchased.
Vehicle costs and carry can create a real gap between a company's gross multiple and the LP's net proceeds. Illustrative $10M SPV at a 3.0x gross outcome, $0.3M of vehicle costs, and 20% carry on remaining profit. Documents may calculate economics differently.
Gross-To-Net Economics
Fees and carry can leave the LP with less than the company's gross return. The gap depends on the costs charged along the way.
View chart data and assumptions
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Gross company proceeds | $30.00M |
| Return of invested capital | $10.00M |
| Vehicle costs | $0.30M |
| Carry on profit | $3.94M |
| Net LP proceeds | $25.76M |
What Reaches the LP?
Suppose a $10 million cheque includes a 2% upfront fee, leaving $9.8 million to buy shares. If those shares double, they return $19.6 million. Profit above the full $10 million paid in is $9.6 million. Taking 20% carry from that profit leaves $17.68 million for the LP before other costs.
The company produced a 2.0x return on the capital it received, while the investor received less than 2.0x on the cash paid. Net proceeds and net MOIC describe that investor result. The timing of the same cash flows determines net IRR.
How the Waterfall Changes the Payout
Now assume $10 million grows to $30 million. The gross profit is $20 million. Under a simple 20% carry calculation, $4 million goes to the sponsor and $26 million remains before other fees, expenses, and taxes.
The terms define what counts as cash paid in, whether gains and losses are pooled, and when carry is due. Even after a sale, reserves or later bills may reduce the cash left. The headline exit value is therefore not the final LP payout.
Run a loss, a small gain and a large gain through the agreement's payout rules. The examples show where the result changes. If the parties get different answers from the same inputs, the wording needs to be clarified.
Costs Beyond the Fee Schedule
Charges may sit in the SPV, a related firm or the vehicle buying the shares. A markup on the share price costs the LP money just as a stated fee does. Several parties can also charge for the same work, leaving the LP paying twice.
Bills can arise before the stake size or company consent is final. If the deal fails or shrinks, the manager may absorb them, bill investors or split them under a policy. The terms need to say which applies so the LP knows what it could owe.
From 2021 to 2023, more SPVs charged management fees in both size bands reported. Carta studied 2,442 US-based SPVs formed from 2016 through 2023. These were institutional vehicles that invested directly. The share charging a fee does not show the fee rate or the LP's full cost.
Management Fees Became More Common In Carta SPVs
From 2021 to 2023, the share of SPVs charging a management fee rose in both reported size bands.
View chart data and assumptions
| Period | SPVs above $10M | $1M-$10M SPVs |
|---|---|---|
| 2021 | 41% | 38% |
| 2023 | 67% | 57% |
How the Economic Layers Fit Together
- Which fees and costs come out before cash reaches the company?
- How much carry is due if the deal loses money or makes a gain?
- Who pays for legal work, tax, transfers and running the SPV?
- Which records show how gross company value becomes net cash for the LP?
- Who controls cash reserves, later rounds, votes and the choice to exit?
- What is still owed if the stake changes or the deal fails?
The answers let the LP follow its cheque into the deal and trace each charge on the way back. That shows the net cash it could receive.
A Pre-IPO SP Fund Case: The Markup Was Another Economic Layer
In 2022, the SEC alleged that pre-IPO special-purpose funds described fee waivers but did not disclose a share-price markup. Investors paid more for the shares than the manager had paid. The complaint shows why the review must go beyond the stated fee list.
The disclosed terms allowed a management fee of up to 2%.
Other costs could apply before any placement fee. These widen the gap between the share price and the LP's entry cost.
The complaint also alleged hidden markups on top of those costs. If charged, this extra layer would raise the investor's total bill.
Start with the price paid for the shares and trace every charge to the LP's net proceeds. Include any spread kept by the sponsor or a related firm. A fee waiver saves money only if the same cost has not reappeared elsewhere.
Primary source: SEC complaint about pre-IPO fund markups (2022). This case comes from public court records. It does not describe a Frontierspace deal or return.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does 20% carry mean 20% of all sale proceeds?
Carry usually applies to profit after the cash paid in has been returned. The legal payout rules, or waterfall, set the exact result. Their definitions of the base, offsets, costs and timing can all change the amount due.
Which SPV costs should an investor review?
Fees, carry, setup and admin costs all affect the result. Failed-deal bills and payments to the sponsor or related firms through other vehicles can add further costs.