LP Direct Funds vs Fund-of-Funds vs Secondaries Calculator

Compare three ways to invest: direct funds, funds of funds and secondaries. See fees, returns, cash needs, the spread of investments and work needed to oversee them. For pension, endowment, family-office and fund-of-funds teams.

Questions this calculator answers1. How would a mix of direct funds, funds of funds and secondaries change our family office’s cash needs?2. If we put 30% in funds of funds, how much would we keep after fees and carry?3. If we put 20% in secondaries, could we get our cash back sooner?

What this mix could look like

We start with your return assumptions, then take out fees and carry. When cash is called and paid back determines the IRR.

Selected mix net value — Year 12
$194m

100% route comparisons update below from the same assumptions.

Largest cash draw$50.9mPeak negative cumulative net cash flow
Time to target4 yearsTo reach 80% paid-in exposure
Fees and carry$46m0.46x of commitments
Managers to oversee7Across direct, FoF and secondary routes

Running cash position

This shows your running cash position over time. Secondaries may return money earlier, while fund of funds can take longer to pay out.

Break-even: 2032
Total portfolioDirect fundsFund of fundsSecondaries
First money back2027
Break-even2032
Last money back2037

Cash calls and distributions

See when money is likely to be called and when it may come back. Coloured bars show each route; the black line shows the total for that year.

First money back: 2027

Before and after fees

Estimated IRR: 17.4%
Before fees and carryAfter fees and carry
Managers to oversee7Direct + FoF + secondary managers
Underlying fund exposures70Illustrative; holdings may overlap
DiversificationBroadBased on underlying-fund breadth
Admin workModerate17 weighted workload points

How much has been called

This shows how much of your planned commitment has been called. It is not the fair value of the portfolio.

80% called in Y4
Direct fundsFund of fundsSecondariesTarget

How to read this

Direct funds offer more control. They also take more work to choose and oversee managers. Fund of funds spread exposure through one relationship, but add fees and may return cash later. Secondaries may invest and return cash sooner. Their pattern of returns may differ. These are scenarios, not predictions.

Frequently asked questions

Can I use all three routes?

Yes. The sliders always add up to 100%, so you can choose any mix of direct funds, fund of funds and secondaries.

Why do fund of funds cost more?

The model first applies fees and carry for the funds held. It then adds the fund-of-funds layer. Actual terms vary by vehicle.

Why can secondaries improve cash flow?

Secondaries may buy older assets and pay cash back sooner. That can help offset calls from newer primary funds.

What does paid-in exposure mean?

It is the share of your planned commitment that has been called. It is not NAV or a fair-value estimate.

Are the underlying funds all different?

Not always. Different managers can hold the same funds or companies. This is a simple breadth estimate, not a full look-through analysis.

Where do the return assumptions come from?

Each route has its own return multiple before fees. This varies with the Conservative, Base or Optimistic setting. You can change them under Advanced. Fees, carry and cash-flow timing then shape the result. These are scenarios, not forecasts.